SEARCH · COMPARE · BOOK

Car Rental Long Island, New York

Compare car rental offers. Review vehicle options, pickup details and supplier conditions before booking.

White rental car with travel luggage

Find the Best Car Rental Deals

Driver's country of residence is and age is

Car rental suppliers

Supplier information is not yet available for this location.

Flexible cancellation options

Explore free cancellation on eligible deals. Conditions may vary.

Compare car rental prices

Compare prices and rental conditions from multiple suppliers.

Review before you book

Review vehicle options, pickup details and rental terms before booking.

Car rental deals

Loading live car rental offers…

How Much Does It Cost to Rent a Car in Long Island?

Compare average car rental prices by month and see how rental rates vary throughout the year in Long Island.

↘
Cheapest Month AverageJan$46Average daily price
↗
Most Expensive MonthJul$108Average daily price
▦
Yearly Average PriceYearly average$70Average daily price

Monthly Average Car Rental Prices

USD · Average per day
Jan $46 Lowest
Feb $49
Mar $57
Apr $67
May $79
Jun $96
Jul $108 Highest
Aug $105
Sep $89
Oct $74
Nov $61
Dec $55

Long Island summer peak for Hamptons and beaches. Fall foliage (October) in North Fork. Book 2-3 months ahead.

* Prices shown are approximate. Original prices are in USD and converted using real-time exchange rates.

DRIVING INFORMATION

Driving in Long Island: Laws & Information

Essential driving rules and requirements to know when renting a car.

Driving Side
Right
Side of the road
Minimum Age
16
Minimum age to drive
Blood Alcohol Limit
0.08%
Maximum allowed
IDP Required?
No
International Driving Permit
Speed Units
mph
Speed measurement
Seat Belt
Required
Seat belt rules
Toll Roads
Yes
Toll road availability
Emergency
911
Emergency services number

View the Complete Driving Guide for New York

Get detailed information on driving rules, licence requirements, speed limits and useful local tips.

View Full Driving Laws Guide
EXPLORE LOCATIONS

Car Rental Locations in Long Island

Markers show approximate airport or town-centre areas, not confirmed rental desks.

AIRPORT INFORMATION

Airport Guides in New York

Find airport guides for car rentals, parking, and ground transportation.

11 airport guides
Have Questions?

Frequently Asked Questions about Car Rental in Long Island

The minimum age to rent a car on Long Island is typically 21 years old, but this varies by rental company. Drivers between 21 and 24 years old will almost always incur a Young Renter Surcharge, which generally ranges from $25 to $35 per day. This fee is added to the base rental rate and is not an insurance product. Some specialty vehicles, like luxury sedans, large SUVs, or convertibles, may have a higher minimum age of 25. Always check the specific terms for your chosen vehicle class before booking. A valid, unrestricted driver's license held for at least one year is mandatory for all renters, regardless of age.

Yes, you can rent a car on Long Island with a valid driver's license from your home country. If your license is not in English, an International Driver's Permit is strongly recommended and often required by rental agencies. The IDP serves as a certified translation and must be accompanied by your original domestic license. Renters from countries that are not part of a visa waiver program should also be prepared to present a valid passport and proof of their entry date into the U.S. Always verify specific requirements directly with the rental branch before your trip to ensure a smooth pickup process.

Long Island uses all-electronic, cashless tolling, primarily on the Long Island Expressway HOV lanes and bridges like the Throgs Neck and Robert Moses Causeway. There are no traditional toll booths to stop and pay. Most rental cars come with a transponder linked to a plate-pass system. If you use a toll road, the fee is automatically processed, and the rental company will charge the toll amount plus a daily convenience fee to your credit card on file, usually for each day of the rental period after the first toll. You can often opt out of their service and pay tolls on your own by registering your rental's plate on the local toll authority's website.

At Long Island MacArthur Airport, the rental car counters are conveniently located on the first floor of the main terminal, directly across from the baggage claim area. You won't need to take a shuttle bus. After collecting your luggage, simply walk to the designated car rental counters to complete your paperwork and receive your keys. The rental vehicles are parked in a lot just a short walk from the terminal, making the pickup process quick and straightforward. For arrivals after hours, you must arrange a late pickup in advance, as counter staffing matches the airport's flight schedule.

New York State law requires that rental companies provide minimum liability coverage, but this is often insufficient. We recommend a Loss Damage Waiver, which relieves you of financial responsibility if the rental car is damaged or stolen, and Supplemental Liability Protection for third-party claims. If you have personal auto insurance, your policy might extend to a rental car, but check for coverage limits, especially on Long Island's busy parkways. Many credit cards offer collision coverage if you decline the rental company's waiver, but they rarely cover liability. Always verify with your provider before declining any protection.

Free parking at Long Island Railroad stations varies significantly by town and requires a local parking permit in most residential areas. Many commuter lots in towns like Hicksville, Ronkonkoma, and Mineola are restricted to residents with a town-issued sticker during business hours. Non-residents and tourists must use metered daily spots or find a public parking garage. Illegally parked rental cars are subject to ticketing and towing, and you are fully responsible for these fines. Always read the posted signage carefully, as regulations change from one village to the next. Look for commercial parking lots near the station as a guaranteed option.

The most common and recommended fuel policy is 'Full-to-Full.' You receive the car with a full tank and must return it full to avoid extra charges. If the tank is not full, the rental company will refuel it at a per-gallon rate that is typically much higher than local gas station prices, plus a possible service fee. Pre-purchase fuel options let you buy a full tank at the start, but you get no refund for unused fuel. Given the high density of gas stations near all major airports and highways on Long Island, the full-to-full policy is almost always the most economical choice.

Yes, additional drivers can be added to most rental agreements. The additional driver must meet all the same age, license, and identification requirements as the primary renter and be present at the counter. A daily surcharge typically applies, often around $13 to $15 per day per additional driver. In New York State, a spouse or domestic partner is often exempt from this fee, provided they meet the rental qualifications. Employees driving for company business on a corporate rental may also be exempt. Always declare all drivers upfront; an undeclared driver invalidates your insurance coverage and constitutes a breach of contract.

Child safety seats are available to rent, but supply is limited, so booking one in advance is essential. New York State law requires all children under the age of 8 to be restrained in an appropriate child restraint system. Children under 2 must be in a rear-facing seat. Children aged 4 through 7 must use a booster seat. The rental cost for a seat is typically $10 to $15 per day. Many traveling families prefer to bring their own car seats to ensure familiarity and proper fit, especially since airlines allow them to be checked at no charge.

The security deposit amount depends on the vehicle type and payment method. For standard rentals paid with a major credit card, the rental company will place an authorization hold of the estimated rental charges plus an additional deposit, typically between $200 and $400. If you use a debit card, the hold amount is significantly higher, often $500 or more, and comes with stricter identification requirements, like proof of a round-trip travel ticket and multiple forms of ID. A debit card hold is a direct withdrawal from your checking account, and the refund can take up to 14 business days after the rental ends.

Major credit cards like Visa, Mastercard, American Express, and Discover are universally accepted. Using a debit card is possible at many locations but requires additional scrutiny. If you plan to use a debit card, be prepared to present proof of a return travel itinerary, a valid driver's license, and a second form of ID. Cash is almost never accepted to secure a rental; however, some branches may allow cash payments upon return if you previously qualified with a credit card. Prepaid cards and gift cards are not accepted for the initial transaction or deposit.

Taking a standard rental car off-road is strictly prohibited by all rental agreements. This includes driving on sand at beaches like those in Montauk or the Fire Island National Seashore access points. If you require a vehicle for permitted beach driving, which is allowed in limited areas with a special permit, you must look into specialty rental companies that offer 4x4 trucks with the required tire pressure equipment. Any damage from driving a standard rental on sand, including getting stuck, undercarriage damage from salt water, and interior sand contamination, will result in substantial cleaning fees and full liability for repairs.

If your rental car breaks down, first pull over to a safe spot away from traffic. Turn on your hazard lights and then contact the 24/7 roadside assistance number provided on your rental agreement jacket or key fob. Do not attempt your own repairs or call a local mechanic without authorization, as those charges won't be reimbursed. On highways like the LIE or Northern State Parkway, remain in your vehicle with your seatbelt on if pulling over completely isn't safe. If you were involved in a collision, you must also file an accident report with the local police and call the rental branch immediately.

Most prepaid rental bookings include a free cancellation grace period, often up to 48 hours before the scheduled pickup time. If you fail to cancel and simply don't show up, you will typically be charged a no-show fee, which can range from $50 to the full cost of a single day's rental. Pay-at-the-desk reservations usually do not require a deposit and therefore don't incur a cancellation fee, but it's courteous to cancel online so the vehicle can be released. Always review the specific terms at booking, as rates from third-party sites or special sale events may have non-refundable policies.

Most daily and weekly rentals from major companies on Long Island come with unlimited miles, making it perfect for exploring from the Gold Coast mansions to the Montauk Lighthouse. However, unlimited mileage typically applies only to standard sedan, SUV, and minivan categories. Exotic cars, large passenger vans, and some long-term rental rates of a month or more might have a mileage cap, charging $0.25 or more per additional mile. If you are renting one-way or a specialty vehicle, always confirm the mileage policy on your contract to avoid a surprise charge.

When driving a rental car from Long Island into New York City, all crossings like the Queens-Midtown Tunnel, Hugh L. Carey Tunnel, and Triborough Bridge are cashless. Your rental car will likely be enrolled in an automatic plate-pay service. As you pass through, a camera captures the license plate. The rental company later bills the toll amount to your credit card, plus a convenience fee of around $5 to $10 per day the service is used. To avoid these fees, you might consider a personal E-ZPass, but remember to de-register the plate from your account after the rental.

Absolutely, you can rent luxury sedans, sports cars, and convertibles perfect for a Hamptons getaway. These specialty vehicles are in high demand from May through September, so booking far in advance is crucial. The minimum age is usually 25, and you will need a major credit card with a limit sufficient to cover a higher security deposit, which can exceed $750. Mileage may be limited to a specific allowance per day, so confirm the terms if you plan extensive cruising. These vehicles must be returned in excellent condition, free of sand and beach debris.

Unlike larger airports that require shuttle buses, the rental car area at Long Island MacArthur Airport is directly integrated into the main terminal building. After returning your vehicle to the designated car rental return lot, you simply park, remove all your belongings, and take a short, signposted walkway straight into the departures concourse. This eliminates the need to wait for a shuttle and reduces the time you need to allocate before your flight. Be sure to keep the rental contract until you get home, in case of any follow-up questions about tolls or fuel.

Pets are generally allowed in rental cars but must be secured in an airline-approved crate or a pet seatbelt harness during the entire journey. An undisclosed free-roaming pet that sheds excessively or damages the interior will result in a significant cleaning fee, often $250 or more, and you are liable for any tears to upholstery. Service animals legally trained to assist a person with a disability are exempt from all pet restrictions and fees. To ensure a smooth return without extra costs, bring a blanket to cover the seats and vacuum the car before you bring it back.

One-way rentals are available but often incur a substantial drop-off fee. This inter-city fee covers the logistics of returning the vehicle to its home fleet. Dropping off at a different location within Long Island, such as picking up in Melville and dropping off in Riverhead, may have a small fee or no fee at all. However, a one-way rental to New York City airports like JFK or LaGuardia, or to another state, will have a much higher charge, sometimes several hundred dollars. You must arrange the one-way rental at the time of booking; not all vehicle classes are eligible.

Parkways on Long Island, such as the Southern State and Northern State Parkways, have a speed limit generally set at 55 mph. However, they are famous for their low overpasses and winding, narrow lanes. Commercial vehicles, trucks, and many large rental vans or moving trucks are strictly prohibited from all parkways due to headroom clearance issues. Regular passenger rental cars and SUVs are fine. Stick to the posted limit; the parkways are heavily patrolled by county and state police, and speeding tickets issued to a rental car come with an additional administrative processing fee from the rental company.

First and foremost, ensure the safety of everyone involved and call 911 if there are injuries. Then, you must contact the local police to file an official accident report—this is non-negotiable for insurance purposes. While still at the scene, exchange driver and insurance details with any other involved party. Notify your rental company immediately using the emergency number on the rental jacket. Do not admit fault or discuss who was responsible. When you return the car, you must fully complete an incident report form. Failure to file the police report can void all coverage you purchased.

Winter driving on Long Island can include icy conditions and nor'easters that dump heavy snow, especially on the North Shore and East End. Using snow chains or metal studs is not legal and completely unnecessary. The main roads, like the Long Island Expressway, are prioritized for plowing. For winter safety, an all-wheel-drive SUV is a smart choice for a rental. Ensure the rental car has a functional ice scraper and that the tires are in good condition. Remember, if roads become impassable and you must abandon the car, do so in a legal parking spot, as towing fines remain your responsibility.

Unlike major international gateways, duty-free shopping at Long Island MacArthur Airport is very limited. Because the airport primarily handles domestic flights and only a handful of international destinations, you won't find a large, traditional walk-through duty-free store like those at JFK. You may find a small kiosk offering basic spirits and tobacco products duty-free for departing international travelers, but the selection is minimal. For extensive duty-free shopping, you are better off browsing at your destination airport or shopping locally on Long Island for tax-free clothing and shoes under the state's exemption.

Smoking is prohibited inside all terminal buildings, including the rental car center at the airport. Designated smoking areas are located outside the main terminal, well past the baggage claim exit doors. You must use these outdoor areas before you pick up your rental. Smoking inside a rental vehicle is strictly forbidden by all rental companies. If the vehicle is returned with any trace of smoke odor or ash, you will be charged a heavy cleaning fee, typically a flat rate of $250 to $400. This policy applies to all forms of smoking, including vaping.

During peak summer season, particularly from Memorial Day through Labor Day, wait times at the rental counter can easily exceed 30 to 45 minutes, especially on Friday afternoons. The surge of tourists heading to the Hamptons, Montauk, and Fire Island creates a bottleneck at pickup. To avoid the line, we strongly recommend joining the rental company's express membership or loyalty program, which allows you to skip the counter and go directly to your car in many locations. Early morning pickups during the week also see significantly shorter wait times than weekend afternoons.

Gas prices near airports are notoriously high, so it pays to refuel a few miles out. Use common navigation apps like Waze or Google Maps to search for gas stations along the main approach roads. Typically, wholesale clubs like Costco or BJ's offer the lowest prices, but require a membership. Stations along Veterans Memorial Highway or Sunrise Highway, just one or two exits away from the airport, are usually $0.30 to $0.50 cheaper per gallon than the two stations right at the airport entrance. Always save your fuel receipt to show at the counter in case of any dispute.

A standard minivan or a large, three-row SUV like a Suburban is ideal for a family trip to the North Fork wine region. These vehicles comfortably seat 7 to 8 passengers and have cargo space for strollers and coolers. A minivan offers easier access for child seats and a smoother highway ride. When booking, ensure the SUV is a 'Large SUV', not a standard mid-size, to get the extra cargo room you'll need for vineyard purchases. Reserve this class well in advance for autumn weekends, as October is peak vineyard tourism season on Long Island.

Whether you need an International Driver's Permit at the airport depends entirely on your home country's license. If your driver's license is issued in a country that uses the Roman alphabet, like France or Spain, you usually don't need an IDP. However, if it uses a non-Roman script, such as Japanese or Arabic, the rental company at the airport counter will absolutely require an IDP. They need a printed translation to legally verify your credentials. You must obtain the IDP in your home country before your trip; the counter staff cannot issue one for you.

Temporary or provisional paper driver's licenses issued by U.S. states are generally not accepted for car rentals on Long Island. The rental counter requires a permanent, physical plastic card to verify identity and driving privileges. New York State does issue temporary licenses during renewal, but presenting just the paper copy will likely result in a failed rental. If you have lost your permanent card, you will need to provide an alternative valid government-issued photo ID along with a driving record report from the DMV, but this is at the manager's discretion.